We need Online Orders at least 2 days in advance! 

If you need it earlier, please call 513-383-2846 or stop by The Cone

to view our Cakes & Pies in the Display Freezers

ICE CREAM PIES:​​

Serves 8-10 people

8 inch round pie

Customizable

$19.95


Generally In Stock Pies:

Reese's Cup, Oreo, Cookie Dough,

and Pumpkin Pies (September 1st-End of Season)​​

Crunch does contain Gluten

Egg Free!

​Peanut Free!

Crust Contains Gluten

Egg Free!

Peanut Free!​​


Customized Cake & Pie Toppings:

​-M&M   -Reese's Pieces   -Reese's Cups  -Cookie Dough  -Kit Kat  -Heath   -Butterfinger  -Cheesecake   -Snickers  

-Chocolate Chunk  -Oreo  -Golden Oreos  -Buckeyes   -Nestle Crunch   -Caramel Truffles  -Gummi Bears  -Brownies

-Sour Patch  -Pineapple  -Blueberry Topping  -Cherry Topping  -Conemade PB Sauce  

-Hot Fudge   -Premium Caramel  -Marshmallow  -Chocolate Diptop (or our other diptop flavors)

 -And More....it never hurts to ask!!! 


Customized Cakes:

(some of these may also be in stock at The Cone)

-Triple Chocolate (all chocolate Ice Cream, Premium Fudge, Fudge Chunk Brownie, & Chocolate Chunks)

-Orange Creamsicle (Orange Sherbet, Vanilla Ice Cream, Marshmallow, and Vanilla Cake)

-Caramel Toffee (Caramel Mocha Cappuccino Ice Cream, Health Toffee Pieces, & Caramel De Leche)

-Strawberry Shortcake (Strawberry & Vanilla Ice Cream, Homemade Shortcake, Sliced Juicy Strawberries)


Customized Pies:

(some of these may also be in stock at The Cone)

-Banana Cream Pie   -Grasshopper Pie (Oreo, Andes Mints, Mint Sauce)  -Mint Chocolate Chip Pie    

-Reese's Explosion Pie (Reese's Cups and Reese's Pieces with Fudge and PB Sauce)

-Oreo Explosion Pie (Oreos and Golden Oreos with Fudge and Marshmallow Sauce)

   -S'mores Pie   -Strawberry Pie   

-Fried Ice Cream Pie (The Cone's Homemade Cinnamon Powder, Chocolate Diptop and Waffle Cone Pieces. Cherries on Top!)

-Tiramisu Pie (Cheesecake, Chocolate Chunks, Coffee)  -Cherry Cordial Pie  

-Rice Krispie Treat Pie  -Cake Batter Rainbow Sprinkle Pie   -Brownie Batter Pie  

-Coconut Cream Pie   -Malted Milkball Pie   -Turtle Pie  

-Caramel Apple Pie (Seasonal September-End of Season)  

-Pumpkin Cheesecake (Seasonal Mid August-End of Season)     

-And More....it never hurts to ask!!! 



Crust Contains Gluten

Egg Free!

Not Peanut Free

NEAPOLITAN CAKE

Chocolate, Vanilla, & Strawberry

Fudge and Chocolate

Wafer Crunch in the Middle

OREO PIE

Oreo Blended

with Vanilla Ice Cream

Oreo Sandwich Cookies &

​Chocolate Diptop on Top

Ice Cream

Cakes and Pies


*We have a 6 Door Glass Freezer in The Cone's Dining Room that you can preview & purchase 

our Cakes, Pies, Quarts, and Novelties if you do not want to order online!

We also try to keep specialty Cakes/Pies in stock (see Customized Cakes/Pies in Purple Box Below)!*

Only Premium and Brand Name Ingredients! Conemade Naturally flavored Ice Cream!

Made Fresh in Store Daily (not a boring, old factory cake)!

FUDGE CRUNCH CAKE

Chocolate & Vanilla Ice Cream

Fudge and Chocolate

Wafer Crunch in the Middle

FUDGE BROWNIE CAKE

Premium Vanilla Ice Cream

Fudge and Chocolate Chip

Brownies in Middle

REESE'S CUP PIE

Reese's Cups Blended

with Vanilla Ice Cream

Reese's Cups, PB Sauce, &

Chocolate Diptop on Top


Have a question before you order? Feel free to call the number above or email theconegirl@gmail.com!


Example of what our Cakes look like Inside!

(our Pies are mixed together)

Pictured: Reese's Explosion & Fudge Crunch

COOKIE DOUGH PIE

Cookie Dough & Chocolate Chunks Blended with Vanilla Ice Cream

Cookie Dough, Chocolate Chunks, &

​Chocolate Diptop on Top

PUMPKIN PIE

Conemade Pumpkin Sauce and Ginger Snaps Blended with Conemade Pumpkin Ice Cream

Snaps, Buttered Pecans,

Premium Caramel on Top

GLUTEN FREE!!!

Egg Free!

Contains Peanuts​​

Crust Contains Gluten

​Egg Free!

Cookie Dough made in facility with Peanuts

ICE CREAM CAKES:​​

Serves 10-12 people

10 inch round cake

or Mini 8 inch round

Customizable

Starting at $24.95


Generally In Stock Cakes:

Fudge Crunch, Fudge Brownie,

Neapolitan, and Reese's Explosion​​

Brownies DO contain Egg, Gluten, and are made in a facility with Peanuts

Crunch does contain Gluten

Egg Free!

​Peanut Free!

Crust Contains Gluten

Egg Free!

Contains Peanuts​​

REESE'S EXPLOSION CAKE

Conemade Peanut Butter Ice Cream

Fudge and Reese's Cup in Middle

Cups, Pieces, PB Sauce on Top